When Leo De Vries signed with the San Diego Padres, the buzz felt real.
San Diego did not treat him like a depth piece. It paid for upside and projected him as a long-term shortstop. Within months, he was viewed as the most important prospect in its system, especially after years of trading away minor league depth to chase contention.
Now, he’s with the Athletics, and the reaction from fans has been predictable: excitement mixed with skepticism.
A reputation for liquidation
The Athletics have a reputation, and it’s not for failing to develop players. They have actually done that part fairly well over the years. Matt Olson. Matt Chapman. Marcus Semien. Those players became impact big leaguers after coming through the organization. The coaching and evaluation side has rarely been the issue.
The frustration comes later.
Olson and Chapman were dealt before reaching the expensive stages of their careers. The teardown in 2022 sent several recognizable names elsewhere. It felt less like a reset and more like a liquidation. For many observers, it created the sense that the Athletics build talent only to move it.
There is context behind those moves. Payroll limitations and ownership constraints. Competitive windows that closed faster than expected. When a high-ceiling teenager lands in that system, people wonder whether he will ever anchor a contender there or eventually headline another trade package.
De Vries is young, but scouts already point to advanced traits. His plate discipline stands out. The swing is compact and controlled. Power projection exists without selling out for it. Defensively, he looks comfortable at shortstop. Smooth actions. Clean footwork. Strong enough arm.