Blue Jays’ Davis Schneider is leaning into his biggest strength again: ‘Doing some damage’

Davis Schneider doesn’t step up to the plate looking to put the ball in play any way he can. That’s not who he is as a hitter. He’s trying to punch the opposing pitcher in the mouth — and he landed quite the impressive blow in Tuesday’s chaotic, topsy-turvy 9-7 win over the Milwaukee Brewers in extra innings.

For the first six innings, though, Schneider sat idly from the Toronto Blue Jays’ third-base side dugout as he waited for an opportunity. It’s not an easy role to occupy, sitting around for the right situation, which, for him, arrived to lead off the top of the seventh.

As the Brewers brought in left-hander DL Hall, the Blue Jays countered with a move of their own to regain the platoon advantage, inserting Schneider as a pinch-hitter for Nathan Lukes. But the move went for naught, at least during this at-bat, as he wound up striking out on four pitches, whiffing on a high-and-inside heater for strike three.

Before a matchup like this, Schneider would’ve been down in the batting cages under the stadium, preparing to face Hall after being alerted by Toronto’s coaching staff that he’d likely be called upon in this situation. A lot goes on behind the scenes leading up to pinch-hitting situations such as this one, like, for example, taking reps off the Trajekt pitching machine, which can replicate any pitcher’s release point and velocity, before entering the game — a luxury not available on road trips.

Given that Schneider’s largely been utilized in a part-time role this season, capitalizing on every chance that comes his way is just as meaningful as it’d be if he were an everyday player. That’s why his seventh-inning strikeout came with so much weight, and it’s also why his redemption moment two innings later holds even more significance.

Following Eloy Jiménez’s lead-off walk to begin the top of the ninth, Schneider turned on a middle-middle 98.1-m.p.h. fastball from Brewers closer Trevor Megill that nearly cleared the right-centre wall, travelling 394 feet and producing a 111.1 m.p.h. exit velocity — setting a new career-high — that resulted in a ground-rule double.

Schneider, putting on his superhero costume yet again to help fuel another late-game comeback, ultimately came around to score as part of a three-run frame that briefly put the Blue Jays ahead before this game’s wildness necessitated extra innings.

Across 11 games, consisting of just three full appearances without being subbed in or out midway through, Schneider now features three extra-base hits (one home run) and is slashing .250/.400/.458 with a notable 151 wRC+ (100 league average) over 30 plate appearances in 2026.

It’s still early in the season, though you could argue this is the best version we’ve seen since Schneider’s historic rookie campaign three years ago. The encouraging results are one thing, but even more convincing is the mindset and confidence that he possesses throughout all aspects of his craft.

The biggest among them, of course, is the power that Schneider displayed in the ninth inning of Tuesday’s much-needed, 2025-reminiscent victory at American Family Field in Milwaukee.

For a Blue Jays offence seeking thump while George Springer, Alejandro Kirk and Addison Barger are on the injured list, Schneider’s presence is becoming increasingly more important with each passing game. He’s re-emerged as a winning player of late, and since wins have been much tougher to come by in recent weeks, there may soon come a point where he’s needed for all nine innings each game — if we aren’t there already.

CHECK OUT OFF THE ROSTER – NEW EPISODES EVERY WEEKDAY