The Toronto Maple Leafs are allowing Matthew Knies to play through an obvious injury, but analysts and fans are wondering why. The forward recently told the media that he doesn’t feel like there is any risk of further aggravating things, but that’s not really the point.
The Maple Leafs are facing growing questions about their handling of the winger as he continues to gut it out in a season that is now all but officially lost. To make matters worse, the better the Maple Leafs do, the more unlikely their chances of securing a top-five pick. In other words, they’re better off losing, and that means taking Knies out would be beneficial when it comes to their draft odds.
Knies Talked About His Injury
Knies recently addressed his situation, explaining that while the injury isn’t comfortable, he is not in a position where he feels he needs to sit, and noted that most players are ‘battling through something’. The only difference is that the Maple Leafs aren’t in the same position as most teams. Knies says the plan is to evaluate things more thoroughly in the offseason and ensure he returns fully healthy next year. The question becomes, why not do it now?
With the Leafs effectively playing out the season and only a top selection in the draft to lose, the logic of keeping him in the lineup is seriously flawed. Not only is Knies viewed as an important part of the organization’s future, and continuing to play through discomfort could impact the recovery time, but the Leafs essentially need to lose.
Toronto is in a place where its remaining games should be stinkers if a lower finish in the standings would improve the team’s odds of securing a higher first-round pick. That’s what the team should be focused on, knowing that the higher the pick, the more it eventually helps Knies… and Auston Matthews and William Nylander. This isn’t tanking. It’s just being logical. The Leafs aren’t as good with Knies out of the lineup, and that, for now, is not a bad thing.
Critics argue that shutting Knies down would serve two purposes: protecting a valuable asset and subtly improving the team’s draft positioning. If Toronto finishes with one of the NHL’s five worst records (or lands in the top 5 via lottery odds/projection), they keep their own pick—it doesn’t go to Boston. If they finish 6th-worst or lower, the pick goes straight to the Bruins. A late-season slide could push them into that protected top-5 territory.
The Maple Leafs Can Be Giving Good Looks to Young Prospects
This isn’t just about Knies. There’s also frustration surrounding what some perceive as a lack of organizational development. Why aren’t younger players being given more opportunities, especially with little at stake in the standings? This is a time when a handful of Marlies should be allowed to showcase their abilities. The Leafs should want to see them.
Ultimately, the Leafs appear committed to letting Knies play through the injury. Whether that decision proves beneficial—or short-sighted—will likely be judged not by the results of this season, but by how both Knies and the organization look when next year begins.
Next: What If Laughton Was Never a Problem in Toronto?
Discover more from NHL Trade Talk
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
