Note: All statistics are as of May 11
At some point every season, the Brewers’ bullpen stops making sense.
Not bad, necessarily. Just… different.
There’s no clean seventh-eighth-ninth progression. There’s no “this is the closer, this is the setup guy, everyone else fall in line.” Instead, it’s a constant shuffle of arms, innings, and situations that feel like they’re being decided on the fly.
And yet, more often than not, it works.
This year, a big part of that weirdness — and a big part of why it’s working — comes down to Aaron Ashby and DL Hall.
If you’ve watched even a handful of Brewers games this year, you’ve probably felt it. The most stressful inning is almost never the ninth. It’s the fifth when the starter runs out of gas with two on and one out. It’s the sixth when the lineup turns over and the middle of the order is coming up. It’s that one stretch where the game can flip, even if there are still 12 outs left to get.
That’s where Ashby has lived.
He leads the bullpen in plenty of stats, as he’s already up to 19 appearances and 26 innings with a 2.08 ERA, a perfect 7-0 record (those seven wins lead the majors), and 41 strikeouts. That alone stands out, but it’s how those innings are coming that really matters. These aren’t clean innings with nobody on and the bottom of the order due up. Ashby is getting the “this could unravel quickly” moments, and more often than not, he’s shutting them down.
He’ll give you multiple innings. He’ll come in mid-inning. He’ll face righties, lefties, whoever. There’s no clean label for it, but it’s pretty clear what the Brewers think of him: when things start getting dicey, he’s one of the first calls. That’s not a middle reliever or a setup guy. That’s just one of your most important pitchers.
Hall’s role isn’t identical, but it’s cut from the same cloth.
He’s been one of the more reliable arms in the bullpen so far, and like Ashby, he’s not being boxed into a traditional role. Some outings are longer, some are shorter, some are clearly matchup-driven, and some feel like pure feel. The Brewers aren’t asking him to be a one-inning specialist. They’re asking him to take whatever inning is available and turn it into something manageable.
Between Hall and Ashby, they’ve essentially created two malleable pieces that can plug into almost any situation. Starter exits early? They can cover it. Bullpen is taxed? They can stretch out. Tough pocket of hitters coming up? They can take that too.
If you’re trying to map out the Brewers’ bullpen by role, you’re going to drive yourself crazy. There isn’t a traditional structure here. Instead, it’s more about coverage. Ashby and Hall handle the messy middle innings and the multi-inning work, and the rest of the staff combines to get them to the finish line. Even that shifts from game to game.
The Brewers aren’t really managing innings as much as they’re managing problems, and Ashby and Hall are the guys solving the biggest ones.
Here’s the thing: even when it’s working, it doesn’t feel comfortable. You don’t get that sense of “OK, just three outs left.” Instead, you get Ashby coming in with traffic and throwing upper-90s with movement all over the place. You get Hall bouncing between roles. You get Abner Uribe hitting triple digits and occasionally losing the zone. Same with Trevor Megill. You get pitching changes that don’t follow a script.
It feels like the game is constantly on the edge.
And maybe that’s why Brewers fans never fully trust the bullpen, no matter how good the numbers look, because it doesn’t look stable.
But it works because of guys like this.
Take Ashby and Hall out of the equation, and everything gets thinner, fast. Suddenly you’re asking more of the traditional relievers. You’re exposing the lower-leverage arms. You’re burning through pitchers just to get from the fifth to the eighth.
Instead, the Brewers have built in some margin. Not through defined roles, but through flexibility. Ashby and Hall don’t just fill innings — they absorb chaos. They turn messy situations into manageable ones and keep games from getting away before the late innings even arrive.
No two games look the same. No bullpen usage pattern repeats cleanly. And no lead ever feels totally safe.
But somehow, Pat Murphy and this bullpen make it work.
That’s not happening by accident. It’s happening because in the middle innings — the ones that actually decide games — guys like Aaron Ashby and DL Hall are quietly doing the hardest work on the staff, even if it never really feels that way while you’re watching it.