Posted in

Blue Jays defeat Yankees as Trey Yesavage dazzles in the Bronx

Blue Jays defeat Yankees as Trey Yesavage dazzles in the Bronx

Wednesday night at Yankee Stadium was the kind of baseball game that earns its place in the back of your mind for a while.

It had it all: A two-hour rain delay before the start of the game, a pitching duel that actually delivered on the hype, and a one-run win in a game the Toronto Blue Jays desperately needed over the New York Yankees to close the gap in the standings. The Blue Jays, taking the third game of this four-game set, moved their record to 22-27 on the season, picking up their third win in the last five games.

The story of last night begins and ends with Trey Yesavage, who continues to haunt Yankee batters.

Entering Wednesday’s matchup, Yesavage had faced 15 Yankees batters in his MLB career without surrendering a hit, while collecting 10 strikeouts in an otherworldly performance in last fall’s ALDS Game 2 at Rogers Centre. Last night, the Yankees and Yesavage met again, for his eighth career regular-season start and first in the Bronx.
Yesavage went on to strike out eight and yield just two hits through six scoreless innings on 95 pitches, dropping his season ERA to 1.07. Yesavage now owns 19 strikeouts in 11.1 career innings against the Yankees with zero runs allowed. This dominance is gaining a paper trail, and I couldn’t imagine the Yankees’ hitters want another taste of him any time soon.

ICEMAN TURNT 🧊

Ice Trey’s ERA: 1.07 🥶

The fastball was electric all night, and all three of his pitches looked as sharp as they have at any point since that postseason masterclass. The command, the conviction, the sequencing, it was Yesavage at his most complete. Aaron Judge, perhaps the most feared hitter on the planet, walked away with the golden sombrero, going 0-for-4 with four strikeouts, three of which came courtesy of Yesavage.

On the other side, Cam Schlittler was also brilliant. The Yankees’ young ace was dominant through six innings, garnering two earned runs, seven strikeouts, and a 1.50 ERA on the season. Last night was a serious pitchers’ duel, and both arms delivered and then some. The difference in this one came down to one half-inning in the seventh and was truly a dominant battle from both starters all night long.

In the top of the seventh, with Schlittler’s pitch count now skimming 100 pitches with the game still scoreless within seconds, he got into hot water. Single, walk, single, and just like that, Andrés Giménez stepped up with the bases loaded and nobody out. 

What followed was likely the most impressive at-bats of the season. 11 total pitches, seven foul balls, grinding through everything Schlittler threw at him and finally ending it with a heater to a low walk in the first run of the game, subsequently ending Schlittler’s evening.

Giménez exemplified exactly what this lineup needs to do more of. Patience, competitiveness late in counts, and making the pitcher work. The Blue Jays have struggled all year to manufacture offence, and working deep in counts, that at-bat was a masterclass in what they need to do more of.

Two batters later, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. didn’t try to be the hero. He floated a sacrifice fly out to right field, moving the score to 2-0 with a quiet, composed piece of situational hitting. Guerrero Jr. has been under the microscope all season offensively, not that it’s unwarranted for the $500 million man. However, in that moment, recognizing the situation, not doing too much, and delivering a sac fly to add an insurance run is part of what separates great hitters from everyone else, even when the home runs haven’t been coming.

The Yankees, however, started to answer in the bottom of the seventh, getting a pair of pop flies into no man’s land in the bottom of the seventh off Mason Fluharty (remember what I said about luck?). As if that wasn’t frustrating enough, Jesús Sánchez went down hard going after the second one, clutching his chest in visible discomfort and requiring assistance from the training staff before being removed from the game under his own power. 

The good news came postgame, when Blue Jays manager John Schneider confirmed the wind had simply been knocked out of him and that it doesn’t seem to be serious, according to MLB.com’s Keegan Matheson. Sánchez had been hitting .370 over the past two weeks, so that’s a big exhale for this roster.

Jesus Sánchez had the wind knocked out of him, so the #BlueJays wanted to get him off his feet.

They’ll check him out tomorrow, but doesn’t sound too serious.

The two-run lead held until the ninth, when Louis Varland ran into some trouble. A fielding error let Anthony Volpe reach, and with runners on the corners with one out, Paul Goldschmidt tapped one back to the mound to score Cody Bellinger, just the second earned run Varland has allowed this season.

That run also made it a one-run game with the tying run 180 feet away at second base. In that moment, Varland bared down and punched out Amed Rosario to strand the runner and secure his sixth save on the year.

This was the Blue Jays’ fifth win in a one-run game this season. They’ve made a habit of finding ways into these close games, and recently it’s been going alright, and last night at Yankee Stadium, with two losses already in the bank and their backs against the wall, they won the biggest one yet.

The Blue Jays showed up last night, capped by a gold-star seventh inning where they finally looked like a lineup that can grind down an opposing pitching staff. An inning like that could snowball in the right direction for the future and seriously spark the offence. Some power still needs to follow, but if Yesavage and the rest of the rotation keep pitching like this, good results will keep coming.

Thursday will be a bullpen game for the Jays, with Braydon Fisher opening, then Spencer Miles expected in a bulk role against Carlos Rodón to wrap the four-game set. It’ll be a tall task to take on this evening, and I’m willing to bet the Blue Jays will need to generate more than two runs to have a chance of splitting the series.

To summarize, if the Blue Jays want to repeat a run at the division and beyond, especially against the Yankees, it starts with the offence carrying its weight.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *