There is one question the Buffalo Bills need to answer when they open their new stadium: Is the Wall of Fame about football, or is it about everything else?
If it’s about football, then there is absolutely no reason O.J. Simpson should be left off.
Before people get upset, this isn’t defending anything that happened after his playing career. This isn’t about legal cases, controversy, or headlines. This is about one thing only, what O.J. Simpson accomplished wearing a Buffalo Bills uniform.
And from a football standpoint, his résumé speaks for itself.
Simpson became the first player in NFL history to rush for over 2,000 yards in a single season, doing it in just 14 games. Think about that. Players today get 17 games to reach that milestone. He did it in three fewer games, averaging an incredible 143.1 rushing yards per game. That record still stands.
He won the NFL MVP. He was a five-time First-Team All-Pro. He led the league in rushing four times. He made six Pro Bowls. He was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame because of what he accomplished on the football field, not because of anything else.
Those accomplishments didn’t disappear.
The Bills have retired his No. 32 jersey. He remains one of the greatest players in franchise history statistically and historically. Whether people like it or not, the story of the Buffalo Bills cannot honestly be told without O.J. Simpson.
Some will argue that the Bills have every right to leave him off because of his personal life. That’s their choice. But if that becomes the standard, then where does it end? Do we start evaluating every Wall of Fame member based on everything they did after football? Or do we honor what they accomplished between the white lines?
If the Wall of Fame is supposed to recognize the greatest players in franchise history, then personal opinions shouldn’t rewrite football history.
Fans don’t have to celebrate O.J. Simpson the person to acknowledge O.J. Simpson the player.
Those are two completely different conversations.
Sports history is filled with athletes whose personal lives have complicated their legacies. But history doesn’t change because it’s uncomfortable. The record books still exist. The statistics still count. The awards were still earned.
Ignoring Simpson’s football career doesn’t erase it.
In fact, it does the opposite. It makes the Wall of Fame feel incomplete.
Future generations walking through the new stadium deserve to learn about every player who helped shape the Bills franchise. That includes the players fans love, the players they debate, and yes, even the players whose legacies became complicated.
A Wall of Fame isn’t supposed to tell only the easy parts of history.
It’s supposed to tell the truth.
And the truth is simple.
O.J. Simpson is one of the greatest football players to ever wear a Buffalo Bills uniform.
If the Wall of Fame is truly about football, then he belongs on it.
NFL Draft Diamonds was created to assist the underdogs playing the sport. We call them diamonds in the rough. My name is Damond Talbot, I have worked extremely hard to help hundreds of small school players over the past several years, and will continue my mission. We have several contributors on this site, and if they contribute their name and contact will be in the piece above. You can email me at nfldraftdiamonds@gmail.com