Monday night’s offensive slugfest with the Athletics in Las Vegas was nothing short of wild. From Kyle Harrison’s random blowup, where the first pitch of the bottom of the first inning got taken for a ride, to the 15 overturned pitch challenges, or maybe the fact that despite giving up 14 runs as a pitching staff, the Brewers (who lead all of baseball in strikeouts as a team) still managed to strike out 20 hitters in a 12-inning affair.
If you’re a baseball nerd like myself, you love stats. Specifically, you love records and learning about where they compare to other memorable offensive shootouts or pitching dominations. Monday night’s game didn’t even crack some of the top offensive games in recent years, or even all-time as a franchise, but it sure did feel like it. With that, let’s take a look at some of the weirdest, fun, and most memorable games.
August 28, 1992 – Brewers 22, Blue Jays 2 (Box Score)
The most runs scored by the Milwaukee Brewers ever. With about a month left in the 1992 season, the Brewers were 4.5 games back of the Toronto Blue Jays in the American League East division standings. The visiting Brewers went into Toronto and had an offensive explosion that hadn’t been seen in two years (when they scored 20 against the California Angels). In their 20-run victory, the Brewers’ eight and nine hole hitters, Kevin Seitzer and Scott Fletcher, both had five hits apiece, not to mention two other players with four hits in a game that featured 31 hits. That 31-hit outburst also set the mark for most hits in a game franchise history.
August 17, 2019 – Brewers 15, Nationals 14 (Box Score)
If you watched the game on Monday night, you most likely heard Jeff Levering and Tim Dillard reference this game a couple of times, for good reason, too. If you thought the 12-inning, 4:14 affair was long (definitely didn’t help with them playing on the West Coast), then let’s remind you of the old times. No, not that old — just before the pitch clock or the extra-inning runner rule was implemented, or even the designated hitter in the National League.
The Crew traveled to the nation’s capital and played a 14-inning, 5:40 game. This game was special for a couple of different reasons; not only was it the longest game ever played by the Brewers in this era, but it was also the most home runs hit by the team in a game (seven), which tied a record that was set by the 1980 squad. In their slugfest with the Nationals, former MVPs Ryan Braun and Christian Yelich had a multi-home run game with two apiece. Trent Grisham, Mike Moustakas, and Eric Thames also homered.
May 8, 1984 – White Sox 7, Brewers 6 (Box Score)
Sticking with the topic of the longest games in Brewers history, this game probably takes the title of craziest game in franchise history, and arguably, MLB history. We’ve heard the stories from Bill Schroeder over time, but it’s still one of those you’re shocked it happened. And quite frankly, the box score is one of my favorites to look back on.
A 25-inning game that took eight hours (across two days) and had two Brewers’ blown leads. Somehow, the Brewers only burned six pitchers in this game, which is fewer than they used in the game on Monday, and in way fewer innings. It featured four players getting at least 10 at-bats and all but three guys getting a base hit. There are a lot of zeros to be shown on the line score, but what I think is the most frustrating part of it all is that the Brewers had a two-run lead on two separate occasions and blew them both times. Most shockingly, a two-run lead was headed into the bottom of the ninth inning with Rollie Fingers as the closer. This game is one of those moments you wish social media was around for to see the reactions of both fan bases.
May 22, 2000 – Brewers 10, Astros 9 (Box Score)
It was the final year of baseball being played in County Stadium, and it featured the largest comeback in the ninth inning in franchise history. According to Baseball Reference, the Brewers had a 0.13% chance to win the game entering the final inning. But as Yogi Berra once said, “It ain’t over till it’s over.” And that was truly how this game was summed up.
Entering the bottom of the ninth inning, the Crew were down 9-2 before the first seven batters of the inning reached base, bringing the score to 9-6 before recording their first out. Actually, their first two outs, seeing as how it was back-to-back strikeouts from James Mouton and Ronnie Belliard. But the party didn’t end there; the same three guys who began the inning kept it alive to force extra innings. After a scoreless top of the 10th inning, José Hernández walked it off with a home run to left field.
April 28, 2004 – Brewers 10, Reds 9 (Box Score)
Wrapping up our discussion of some of the wildest, jaw-dropping games in Brewers history, let’s end on the biggest comeback win in franchise history. This one’s a bit different, because the Crew found themselves down 9-0 at the top of the fourth inning, and used the whole rest of the game to complete their comeback.
Following an abysmal start from Matt Kinney and a relief appearance from Adrián Hernández, the pitching staff held its part of the bargain for the remaining six innings by allowing no runs on just two hits. Then, the offense broke into the scoring column with an RBI base hit from Lyle Overbay. After slowly chipping away at their deficit and bringing the game’s score to 9-6, Bill Hall came through, for just the first of two times that day, with a bases-clearing double that tied the game at 9-9. Later in the bottom of the 10th inning, he dropped a walk-off sacrifice bunt to win the game for the Brewers.
It’s only fitting that Pat Murphy wants his team to have the mindset of a woodpecker, because, to be honest, that’s just how the Brewers have been throughout time, despite maybe not being as consistent as they are today.